The Broad Definition of Immersive Sims: A Different Perspective

Skyrim and Baldur’s Gate 3 may not be the first games that come to mind when thinking about immersive sims, but according to Arkane founder Raphael Colantonio, they fit the bill. In an interview with PC Gamer, Colantonio challenges the conventional idea of what qualifies as an immersive sim, bringing a more encompassing perspective to the table.

Blurry Boundaries

Colantonio argues that the genre of immersive sims is more expansive than commonly believed. He points to Bethesda and Obsidian games as prime examples of immersive sims, citing their reliance on simulation elements. While acknowledging that these games may be less physical than Arkane’s titles, he emphasizes that they still feature immersive qualities through player interactions and choices.

Contrary to the notion that immersive sims must adhere to a specific formula, Colantonio suggests that there is room for variation within the genre. He highlights the distinction between action-based immersive sims and RPG-based immersive sims, illustrating that different approaches can lead to equally engaging experiences. This flexibility in defining immersive sims opens up new possibilities for game developers to experiment and innovate.

Beyond the traditional examples, Colantonio mentions Larian Studios’ Baldur’s Gate 3 as a game that can be considered immersive sim-adjacent. Despite its turn-based mechanics, he recognizes the game’s potential for immersive storytelling and player agency. The unconventional choices and creative playstyles embraced by the community demonstrate the wide-ranging possibilities within the immersive sim genre.

Colantonio concludes by highlighting the subjective nature of labeling a game as an immersive sim. The boundaries of the genre are fluid, with varying interpretations among players and developers. What constitutes an immersive sim for one person may differ for another, leading to ongoing debates and discussions within the gaming community. Ultimately, the definition of immersive sims remains open to interpretation, inviting exploration and interpretation from diverse perspectives.